Thursday, June 7, 2012

Oversexualization Article

It is no secret that sexual references and imagery taint our media and society, but to what extent does this affect the young adolescent female population?  I recently read an Article written by Jennifer R. Curry and Laura H Choate entitled "The Oversexualization of Young Adolescent Girls: Implications for Middle Grade Educators.  This article was eye opening and sickening in many ways.  Below you will find the points from the article that I find key.

According to Erikson, adolescents are attempting to resolve a sense of personal identity over role confusion.  This is a natural part of life that is essential to becoming a  well-rounded, self-assured adult.  As young adolescent girls attempt to define who they are, they are constantly bombarded with portrayals of what culture expects of them both in how they look and how they act.  When shopping, young girls are exposed to pictures of petite models who are beautiful and scantily clad.  Popular lingerie stores now offer "tween" departments boasting pushup bras in sizes as small as 30AA.

At checkout counters, tween magazines are found emblazoned with cover articles featuring the best makeout tips, popular crash diets, or 50 moves to "turn him on".  Television commercials and shows depict the hot, skinny girls as heroines and the plump, homely girls as their sidekick.  What all this says to young adolescent girls is that in order to be successful, you must also be beautiful and sexy.  Girls begin to judge their self worth as if they were objects from a third-person perspective.  Instead of "how do I look and feel," they ask themselves "how do others think I look?"

This "self objectification"  leads to an obsession about how they look and appear to others, leaving little energy to focus on other things, including academia.  This is where middle-school educators come into play.  According to a study by Herr, "girls often emerge from middle school with a lowered sense of self-esteem, a discouragement with school, and a school performance that does not match earlier achievements" (1996).   The more time a girl worries about how she looks to other people, the less time she can devote to her studies, leading to a drop in grades and performance. Body dissatisfaction is also associated with a number of other factors including poor self-esteem, depression, eating disorders, and early onset smoking.

Middle school teachers and administrators should teach their students about techniques used to digitally enhance models.  Models' photos are increasingly edited to make them slimmer, tanner, more voluptuous, and essentially more sexy.  The women that these girls are idolizing do not actually exist.  They are simply a figment of an editor's imagination.  Therefor, they are holding themselves to an impossible standard.  This "media literacy" technique can help girls combat negative self-worths due to media influence.

Additionally, teachers should teach their students empathy.  This is the age when girls become the most catty to one another.  Teachers should combat gossip due to appearance by having the students role play to examine how the victim of gossip may feel.

Another harmful effect of the oversexualization of young adolescent girls is that it has caused a rise in sexual harassment.  Middle school teachers must be especially aware of this and proactive in combatting it.  Both boys and girls at this age are ill informed of what constitutes sexual harassment and they may consider these actions normal or even desires. School is supposed to be a safe and welcoming place for all students.  Girls who have been sexually harassed or even assaulted are less likely to attend school and more likely to withdraw themselves socially.  Middle school teachers and administrators must adopt a zero-tolerance policy on sexual harassment.

Overall, teachers and parents of young adolescent girls must educate themselves on the implications of oversexualization of young girls.  Growing up in today's world is not the same as most of our experiences at this age.  Girls are increasingly pressured to look, act, and be sexy.  This can have vastly negative impacts on their education, self-esteem, and psychosocial development.  It is our job as future educators to recognize these effects and do our best to curb this trend.

17 comments:

  1. I think this article is VERYY informal and something that all adolescent teen girls should read for their best interest. It is awful that in today's society that most girls are more worried about their appearance rather than their grades. Looking back on it I was more than likely the same way, but if I could go back knowing what I know now my looks and the way my hair looked and the clothes I wore would be the least of my worries. I think that girls in their early twenties that know what I know now that being skinny and tan is not the important things in life. I also think people in the early twenties should also go speak to schools and express what really matters in life and even express to them how they can relate to them in their adolescent years! This is a topic I myself feel very passionate about and for a girl to attempt to make themselves "sexy" should not even be in their thinking at this day and age of their life! Every one should remember, being different is ok!! This is why I am so weird myself.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Amber,
    first I want to say that I absolutely love what you have done to your blog! It makes things more fun and interesting. Reading your blog about sexuality really makes me go back down memory lane. We grew up together so I know you know exactly what I am talking about. It makes me go back and think about the "popular" crowd, and how all the guys were drooling over them all the time. I really did not care about my appearance that much growing up, and even to this day as you can tell I do not wear make up that much anymore. Do you remember the girls that I am talking about that tried so hard, and they always made it known, because they were always trying to wear tighter jeans, lower shirts, and shorter skirts? I believe that this is a huge issue in middle schools, and teachers need to be able to speak their minds. Teachers should also be able to keep these types of issues from happening.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Amber,
    While I was reading your summary, I was having mental images of myself in middle school. I also remember thinking "Do the boys think I am fat?" "Do I look like this model?" I can not imagine how bad it is now for young girls, if it was that bad when we were that age. It is so sad and makes me want to help these girls so much and tell them my own experiences. I would want to tell them what beauty really means because it definitely does not mean daisy duke shorts with your booty hanging out, with short shirts, and tons of makeup. Hopefully one day, I will be able to young girls what real beauty is.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Amber,
    This summary really hit home being a girl who, like most girls, had a tough time in middle school. I remember constantly questioning my looks and comparing myself to other girls. I also remember memorizing everything in Seventeen magazine, hoping to God it would automatically make me prettier. Nowadays, I think that the insecurities that girls have in middle school are even worse, and I can't imagine how horrible it must be. I think the idea that the article had of showing girls how digitally altered ads and photos in magazines really are so that they will see it's not even real. Girls need to learn what real, true beauty is, and being women I think that modeling what true beauty is on the inside and out is something us teachers need to model for our students. Showing them empathy and that we know what they are going through will hopefully show them the light as well.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Amber,
    I thought you did a great job on this article! I was by far the ugliest kid in middle school and I remember it well. I remember trying so hard to "get pretty" when middle school is just an awkward time of your life. This article gave me a lot of good ideas on how to deal with this situation as a teacher. Beauty truly comes from the inside and I hope I can someday teach that to my students (especially the girls).

    ReplyDelete
  6. Amber,
    Your blog was very intersting and well written. I agree that girls feel like they have to be sexy in order to be socialy excepted. They turn to magazines and social media outlets to find ways that they think will help them to become desired by their peers. Adolescents are just all trying to fit into society and lack individualty. I also agree with your statement about helping girls realize that they do not need to be "sexy" to be beautiful. It is important to educate girls on self esteem and self worth. This form of education can allow girls to see behind those fake digitaly altered magazines and be able to except themselves without the need for heavy makeup or sexy clothing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey Amber,
    Great job! This article is so interesting. I agree that the symbols society portray of what we should look like are absolutely wrong. No real woman looks like that. Notice I said real! Like we talked about in class today, they are altered with photoshop programs. The message society puts out for girls is scary. Every child needs to know that they are beautiful in their own skin. This is something I try to tell my 14 year old sister all the time. She is a competitive gymnast and is barely 100 pounds and beautiful. A few weekends ago we went swimming and she said "I am too fat for a two piece". I wanted to slap her! I constantly have to remind her that she is beautiful, no matter what!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Amber,
    I have a 12 year old niece that I could just slap, because of the clothes she wears. I try to tell her that the clothes make her look like a hoochie, but she shrugs it off. I am always asking my sister "her mother" why she lets her wear clothes like that. I feel like I can't preach to her to much because I was that girl in middle school. I wore skimpy clothes and wanted all the attention from all the guys. Now I look back and I see her just like I was. I try to tell her that it does not make her cute, but it could make her a victim of sexual harassment or maybe something worse. Girls these days wear things that show to much and I do not understand why the parents allow it. The day my girls come out of their room with a short skirt or a shirt showing cleavage is the day I will make them wear long skirts and dresses for the rest of their life.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Amber,
    This article is SO true! Young girls today think they need to look like the girls they see in the media. I think this is absolutely aweful because the girls they see in the media today are made to look totally different than what they should look like. This is why I believe that school uniforms are a great idea. With the way that the world is today, school uniforms are an all around better idea. This way there will be no problem when it comes to dress code. I also think that a program for middle school girls should be offered about how to be themselves. These girls need to see that they are beautiful and that they do not need to look like the women they see on tv. I loved reading your article and I agree with you about how disturbing this is. Great blog!

    ReplyDelete
  10. This article makes me think of my 12 year old sister in the 7th grade! She is so skinny and tone and she is always saying... i need to loose weight. i need to loose weight. It drives me crazy! I know that this age group worries over nothing about friendships, looks, and weight. My mother taught an 8th grade all girls health/sex education course. When asked to teach the course, she asked if the person was crazy because she didn't think she could do it. My mom tried to stress to the girls about whats important and whats not in the life of an 8th grader. I think all schools should have a specific course just to get girls through the hardships of being a young adolescent.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is one thing that can be done in advisory periods too...if middle schools have/use them as such. We will talk about those today.

      Delete
  11. Nice job on the article! It reminds me of myself during middle school days. I was one of those girls that wanted what every other girl had to fit in and be pretty. Everyone always asked you where did you get your outfit from. Girls did make fun of other girls for not having the stylish clothes. I feel like the clothes middle school girls wear are just going to get worse with time. Girls are always looking in the media and magazines for the latest "sexy" outfit.

    ReplyDelete
  12. For those of your interested, here is the link for the Dove video that is so great: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_aDpmfAzxI

    ReplyDelete
  13. Amber, let me just say, I love your creativeness for your blog page. Your summary of article was great. I remember when I was in Middle School, it was very tough for me because of some occurring events. Middle school is when young girls start to to question their beauty and intelligence among others. It is so important to let them know beauty is not what they see on television or magazines. The media is a horrible and bad influence on young girls in middle school.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The summary of this article was great, Amber. I was glad we chose this article and now I want to read it! It definitely takes me back to middle school days when all the girls around me wore tons of makeup, tight fitting clothes and bragged about their cleavage/push up bras. I love the new Dove campaign, and I feel like there should be more opportunities for self-image and confidence maybe with conventions or retreats or something. I feel like it's really important in middle school for it to be addressed in boys and girls. It was really interesting to see my practicum class at Armstrong because my class was filled with all boys and one girl, who basically acted like the boys. I was able to see the male side of self-image and confidence issues and it was certainly an eye opener. I think I often forget that males can have just as many self-image and confidence issues as females.

    ReplyDelete
  15. It is crazy how times change and how the media distorts the view of reality in so many ways. The media is harming girls and guys perceptions of how things really are, but some of the blame has to be given to parents. I think some of it goes back to what socioeconomic status people are in. I do not have the time to explain and give research on what I mean, but people are different and have different parenting methods. Many upper class students have more availability to the glamour and hype that the media presents.

    ReplyDelete
  16. How do we as teachers deal with these types of situations, when we know that they can hurt other students and themselves, but parents and students do not see it?

    ReplyDelete